Make maximization compatible with tiling & add toggle maximization

rc.lua

@@ -370,7 +370,7 @@ clientkeys = gears.table.join(
         {description = "Move left", group = "window_tiling"}
     ),
     awful.key({modkey,}, "Up",
-        tiling.key.maximize,
+        tiling.key.toggleMaximized,
         {description = "Move left", group = "window_tiling"}
     ),
 

tiling.lua

@@ -2,67 +2,66 @@
 
 local awful = require("awful")
 
--- Check if geometries are the same
+-- Placements
-local isTiled = function(c, geometry)
+local leftTileGeometry = awful.placement.scale
-    return c.height == geometry.height and c.x == geometry.x and c.y == geometry.y
-end
-
--- Tile a window to the left
-local tileToLeft = function(c)
-    local apply = awful.placement.scale
     + awful.placement.left
     + awful.placement['maximize_vertically']
-    return apply(c, {honor_workarea=true, to_percent = 0.5})
+local rightTileGeometry = awful.placement.scale
-end
-
--- Tile a window to the right
-local tileToRight = function(c)
-    local apply = awful.placement.scale
     + awful.placement.right
     + awful.placement['maximize_vertically']
-    return apply(c, {honor_workarea=true, to_percent = 0.5})
+local maximizedTileGeometry = awful.placement.scale
+    + awful.placement['maximize']
+
+
+-- Check if geometries are the same
+local geometryEquals = function(geo1, geo2)
+    return geo1.width == geo2.width and geo1.height == geo2.height and 
+        geo1.x == geo2.x and geo1.y == geo2.y
+end
+
+-- Try to apply a tile placement to a client
+-- return false if it changed nothing
+local applyTile = function(c, geometry)
+    local initialGeometry = {
+        x = c.x,
+        y = c.y,
+        width = c.width,
+        height = c.height
+    }
+    local newGeometry = geometry(c, {honor_workarea=true, to_percent = 0.5})
+    return not geometryEquals(initialGeometry, newGeometry)
 end
 
 return {
     key = {
         tileRight = function (c)
-            local initialGeometry = {
+            c.maximized = true
-                x = c.x,
+            if not applyTile(c, rightTileGeometry) then
-                y = c.y,
-                width = c.width,
-                height = c.height
-            }
-            local newGeometry = tileToRight(c, c.screen)
-            if isTiled(initialGeometry, newGeometry) then
                 local newScreen = c.screen.get_next_in_direction(c.screen, "right")
                 if newScreen ~= nil then
                     c.screen = newScreen
-                    tileToLeft(c)
+                    applyTile(c, leftTileGeometry)
                 end
             end
         end,
         tileLeft = function (c)
-            local initialGeometry = {
+            c.maximized = true
-                x = c.x,
+            if not applyTile(c, leftTileGeometry) then
-                y = c.y,
-                width = c.width,
-                height = c.height
-            }
-            local newGeometry = tileToLeft(c, c.screen)
-            if isTiled(initialGeometry, newGeometry) then
                 local newScreen = c.screen.get_next_in_direction(c.screen, "left")
                 if newScreen ~= nil then
                     c.screen = newScreen
-                    tileToRight(c)
+                    applyTile(c, rightTileGeometry)
                 end
             end
         end,
-        maximize = function (c)
+        toggleMaximized = function (c)
-            local axis = 'vertically'
+            if not c.maximized then
-            local f = awful.placement.scale
+                c.maximized = true
-                + (axis and awful.placement['maximize'] or nil)
+            else
-            c.geometry = f(c.focus, {honor_workarea=true, to_percent = 0.5})
+                if not applyTile(c, maximizedTileGeometry) then 
-            c.position = "maximized"
+                    c.maximized = false
+                end
+            end
         end
     }
 }